ADOT dumps 99th Avenue option for South Mountain

West Valley View
3/8/2006
Daniel Burnette, staff writer
 

The proposed 99th Avenue alignment of the future South Mountain Freeway has been tossed, but a new concern has arisen in Avondale over the future reconstruction of the Loop 101-Interstate 10 interchange. 

The 99th Avenue alignment would be too disruptive to the local economy, said Matt Burdick, spokesman for the Arizona Department of Transportation. Burdick announced that decision the evening of March 6 during an Avondale City Council meeting. 

The state Department of Transportation has the responsibility of drawing up the plan for the freeway lanes that would connect Loop 202 on the south end of the Valley of the Sun with Interstate 10, somewhere west of downtown Phoenix. 

That “somewhere” has been the subject of concern in the Southwest Valley, where officials in Avondale and Tolleson have worried about the disruption to businesses along the proposed 99th Avenue alignment. 

An advisory committee to the state Department of Transportation recently concluded that the 99th alignment could destroy the economy of Tolleson, a small community between west Phoenix and Avondale that has a concentration of warehouses in the area. 

The western edge of Avondale’s AutoMall would have to be bulldozed if that alignment were used. 

The concern for Avondale now shifts to how the Loop 101-Interstate 10 interchange will be fashioned. 

The so-called “partial reconstruction” proposal would leave intact the current access at McDowell Road and Loop 101. But the so-called “Full Reconstruction Alternative” would eliminate the McDowell Road access, requiring motorists on Loop 101 who wish to visit the retail centers at 99th Avenue and McDowell to exit a mile north. 

“When you talk about full reconstruction, that kills everything on McDowell Road, in my opinion,” Councilman Jason Earp said. “People aren’t going to want to drive a mile north and then come back to eat or go to a movie.” 

David Fitzhugh, Avondale’s assistant city manager, agreed. In a report to the City Council, Fitzhugh stated, “This alternative would affect three of Avondale’s most important sales tax generators — the 313,000-square-foot Gateway Crossing retail center and the 745,000-square-foot Gateway Pavilion power center, and the Avondale AutoMall, the city of Avondale’s largest single source of sales tax revenue.” 

“This alternative also directly impacts two existing auto dealerships and potentially affects access to those remaining,” Fitzhugh said. “Based on review of the aerial photographs, the proposed interchange appears to eliminate the existing private road, Dealer Drive, which provides primary access to the dealerships.” 

The AutoMall generates about 20 percent of Avondale’s sales tax revenue, Fitzhugh said, all of which go to basics services such as parks, libraries and critical services such as police and fire protection. 

“Not only would this alternative be devastating to the commercial and employment corridors adjacent to the freeway between 99th Avenue and Avondale Boulevard, it would also drive away the potential for future commercial and employment ventures that are attracted by the ease of access to the freeways,” Fitzhugh predicted. 

The state Department of Transportation anticipates making a decision on the issue this spring. Construction isn’t expected to begin until 2009. 

“Who makes the ultimate decision?” Earp asked. 

State transportation director Victor Mendez will decide whether to allow the final plan to go forward to the Maricopa Association of Governments, a regional planning authority made up of Maricopa County and most of the municipalities in the county, Burdick said. 

Because federal money will pay for part of the South Mountain Freeway, the Federal Highway Administration also will have a say in how and where the South Mountain gets built, Burdick said. 

Daniel Burnette can be reached by e-mail at dburnette@westvalleyview.com.