Freeway opponents start petition initiative

Ahwatukee Foothills News
12-9-05
By Doug Murphy

If you ask, Melanie Pai will tell you she is no different than anyone else.

"[I'm] just a mom. I work a 60-hour week like everyone else."

But that didn't stop her from leading the charge with a petition drive to stop the Loop 202 South Mountain Freeway from being built on Pecos Road.

She opposes just about everything connected with the freeway from the proposed route along Pecos Road, to the 10 lanes of freeway that will cut through South Mountain Park, to the displacement of families, and most of all, she is opposed to the pollution a freeway would bring forcing families to play roulette with children's health.

"I think we have a right to protect our children," said Pai, who pointed out that about 7,000 students will be attending school within a block or two of the freeway.

"So I thought a petition would be appropriate," she said.

At the first meeting of PARC, Protecting Arizona's Resources and Children, on Dec. 4, she had about 35 volunteers eager and ready to circulate petitions.

She expects many more at the next meeting: 3 p.m. Dec. 18 at Pecos Park.

"She is very articulate," said Jim Jochim, who attended the first meeting and is gathering signatures.

What mobilized Pai was her inability to find anyone accountable for the proposed Pecos Road alignment.

The Arizona Department of Transportation will recommend a final route for the entire Loop 202 in 2007, but based upon a recommendation by the South Mountain Citizens Advisory Team and only after input from the cities of Phoenix, Laveen and Tolleson. That route then will go to the Federal Highway Administration for final approval.

"It is a convoluted process that is designed to obscure what is poor planning," Pai said.

So she decided that a petition sent to Phoenix Mayor Phil Gordon and Gov. Janet Napolitano would get the message across.

The petition doesn't have any legal authority, but will be considered by ADOT when it comes down the final decision.

"We'll take input such as that, and any other input," said Matt Burdick, a spokesman for ADOT.

The petition also draws attention to the freeway's opponents, an important factor in next year's election for legislators and governor.

"What I'm looking for is to hold these politicians accountable for whatever decision they make," Pai said.

"The other thing, we want them to know is if they don't consider the needs of children, the needs of the community, there will be political and legal repercussions."

The Loop 202 South Mountain Freeway has been on the books since 1988, running east to west along Pecos Road from Interstate 10 by Ahwatukee Foothills, through a corner of South Mountain Park and reconnecting with I-10 in the West Valley somewhere between 51st Avenue and the Loop 101/I-10 interchange.

In Ahwatukee Foothills, a preliminary estimate shows 255 homes would have to be demolished to make way for the freeway if it were built above ground. If the freeway were built below ground level to reduce noise, roughly 695 homes would have to be demolished.

Some of the 255 homes were built in the freeway right of way when the state didn't have the money to buy the land in the mid-1980s.

Depending on which route is approved in the West Valley, anywhere from 120 to 780 homes could be demolished, including mostly new homes built in the last few years.

The current timeline calls for the citizens advisory team to recommend a final route in the West Valley early next year and the final route in the East Valley by the end of 2006 or early in 2007, with the final design completed in 2008 and construction to run from 2009-2015.

For information on the freeway, visit www.southmountainfreeway.com

Pai said that PARC is still working on a Web page.

The reporter can be reached at (480) 898-7914 or by e-mail at dmurphy@aztrib.com.

 More about PARC

Protecting Arizona's Resources and Children

Contact: Melanie Pai, (480) 678-0407 or melaniepai@yahoo.com

Next meeting: 3 p.m. Dec. 18, at Pecos Park

 Chances for success

Grass-roots opposition to freeways have had mixed success.

In Phoenix, opponents to state Route 51 were unsuccessful 20 years ago. But those opposed to the Paradise Parkway, which would have cut east-to-west through Phoenix near Camelback Road, won a victory when that freeway was erased from the maps.

A recent case in nearby Nevada may be an example for opponents to the South Mountain Freeway.

In that case, Nevada and federal highway officials settled a lawsuit in June brought by the Sierra Club that had stalled the widening of a key stretch of highway through Las Vegas because of health concerns at three nearby schools.

In the settlement the government agreed to install air filtration systems at the schools along U.S. 95 between downtown Las Vegas and the city's northwest section. The Federal Highway Administration also agreed to study air quality at up to five sites near highways around the nation to gauge the impact of freeways on air quality around schools.

In return, the Sierra Club dropped the lawsuit that had been heard in federal court earlier in the year.

The Sierra Club had argued that project planners failed to account for people living near the widened freeway who might be sickened by exhaust from increased automobile traffic.